Slideshow image

Does Humility Mean Pretending You Agree?

“But when Peter was come to Antioch, I withstood him to the face, because he was to be blamed.”Galatians 2:11 (KJV)

Humility doesn't require us to call something right when we believe it's wrong.

Recently, someone asked me whether agreeing with a person who is wrong would become a kind of lying. That's a fair question, especially when Christians are told that peace means keeping quiet.

Paul, an apostle who helped lead the early church, speaks from real experience. Peter was one of the twelve disciples who walked with Jesus, yet Paul says he confronted him face to face because Peter was wrong.

Peter had been eating with Gentile believers, people who weren't Jewish.

When certain religious men arrived, he pulled away because he was afraid of what they would think. His actions made it look like the grace of Jesus wasn't enough to bring everybody to the same table.

Paul didn't pretend to agree. The gospel was being blurred, so he spoke.

This is where we usually make one of two mistakes. We stay silent because we're afraid of conflict, or we use the truth as permission to embarrass somebody.

Paul did neither. He addressed the person involved and named the issue that mattered.

The goal wasn't to prove that Paul was smarter than Peter. The goal was to protect the truth that people are made right with God through Jesus, not through religious performance.

Paul explains the posture elsewhere:

"But speaking the truth in love, may grow up into him in all things, which is the head, even Christ:"

Ephesians 4:15 (KJV)

Truth and love are in the same sentence here.

Love without honesty can leave a harmful lie standing. Honesty without love can become pride wearing a Bible verse.

Jesus never asked us to win arguments. He gave Himself to save people who were wrong, including us.

That grace lets us speak without acting superior because the truth didn't come from us in the first place.

You're allowed to disagree but you're also responsible for the heart you bring into the disagreement.

Here's how to disagree with humility today:

1. Name the actual issue.

Write one plain sentence about what you believe is wrong. If the sentence is mostly about the other person's character, you're probably no longer correcting the issue.

2. Speak to the person, not around them.

When it's safe and appropriate, ask for a private conversation. Paul went to Peter's face. He didn't build a crowd first.

3. Hold your feeling against the Word.

Fear may tell you to agree so nobody gets upset, while pride may tell you to keep talking until you win. Bring both feelings under the truth and love of Christ before you answer.

PRAYER

Heavenly Father,

I've confused humility with silence, and I've also used honesty to defend my pride.

Give me a heart that cares more about truth and people than about winning.

Show me when to speak and when to leave an argument alone.

Help me address the real issue without attacking the person.

Keep the gospel at the center of every hard conversation.

In Jesus' beautiful name we pray. Amen.